Monday, September 21, 2020

WHERE DOES ONE PLACE THEIR TRUST?

When Eric Fingerhut began his service as JFNA's new CEO and President, he was joining an organization of strangers to him. Certainly, for better or worse, he received guidance from the lay leaders who played the most significant role in his hiring. And, no doubt, he brought some mid-level professionals with him from Hillel as JFNA's budget reflected a small FTE increase in the Office of the President. And, naturally, Fingerhut spent his first months getting the JFNA "lay of the land" from its most senior professionals. 

And, Eric not being a rookie in Jewish organizational life, a strong and respectedf professional of reputed good judgment, of whom one would have expected that after the "break in period," we would have seen significant changes at the very top of the JFNA organization chart.

But...no. In the face of the pandemic, JFNA announced that it had down-sized by 37 persons, most of them mid-level professionals -- you know, as in almost every non-profit, those who are doing the work in the trenches. And the long-serving SVP Marketing and Communications left as well (and, relatively promptly, replaced). Pre-pandemic, Fingerhut announced that, in addition to his role as CEO/President he would serve as the head of FRD, after that position was vacated -- and, inasmuch as JFNA no longer appears to engage in FRD, once its primary fundtion and the one most demanded by the communities, this should not unduly burden him.

And, what is JFNA left with -- at the least, its two most senior professionals: its Executive Vice-President and its SVP Global Operations and Director General JFNA Israel. Now, to be honest I don't know much about what either of these prfessional leaders do but I'm pretty sure that whatever they may do includes: protecting and supporting each other; identifying other JFNA professionals who have been or will be sacrificed to the economic fall-out of the pandemic but not them; and, of course, kissing up to the CEO (a pattern they established early on with Eric's predecessor for whom the delivery of a constant supply of Diet Cokes was a high point of service) and to every lay leader whom they associate with JFNA power. 

And, whatever their roles really are these two drink very, very well from the Jewish money spigot. Yes $409,000 to the EVP; $347,000 to the SVP Global Ops. If the CEO was trying to identify additional  savings, he need have looked no further. But he did not. WHY NOT? I have no doubt that over the years, these two senior professionals have looked to a small groiup of lay leaders to succor their support. And, if not otherwise successful, this twosome proved the benefits of that support. And those lay leaders, recirculated through the JFNA leadership ranks as if they had demonstrated success in their prior roles, became reliant on these pros for information, and for mutual support -- effectively rewarding the pros' loyalty to them confusing that personal loyalty with loyalty to the organization.

More's the pity, friends.

G'mar tov.

Rwexler

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

My understanding is that the EVP has been put to the side and Eric's Chief of Staff (amazing how many CEOs now have a Chief of Staff) is the one he turns to.

Anonymous said...

How many times does it need to be said that the Israel (Global) operations and, of course, their "leader" are a total waste of time and resources?
Why the SVP doesn't see this is beyond comprehension, unless of course he does see it and just prefers to ignore it rather than do something about it. Either way, it is clear that he is no manager.
That both of them are overpaid and should be retired should also be crystal clear to anyone that has any basic managerial skills.
So what does that say about about JFNA's top professional and lay leadership?

The SVP position was created because the former top gun was unable to manage the organization.
The Israel Office should be a small representative office - not an operational unit and not the current overstaffed entity that it has been grown into, led by an empire builder who is attempting to compete with our partners and other Israeli NGOs and doing more damage than good.

The solution is right in front of you Eric. You don't need either of these senior positions and should redefine and drastically downsize your footprint in Israel.
The time is long overdue for serious zero based budgeting, don't you think?

Anonymous said...

JFNA needs to be closely examined by an independent group of leaders -- those not looking for promotions or in the pocket of the current leadership. One would think that Mark and Eric would want exactly that -- just kidding.

Anonymous said...

Bridgespan?
Bridgespan?
Anybody asking the question as to why JFNA spent the federations' close to $1 million for this consulting group?
What were they hired to do? Certainly not to look at JFNA as an operating entity.
Oh, they did help devise a new formula for dues. And how is that working out?
Amazing that nobody on the JFNA board asked a question about looking inward for $1 million.

Anonymous said...

Who reads this stuff?
There has to be a way to get it distributed to a wider federation and community audience.
That is the only way to get something to happen and something certainly needs to happen ASAP (if it isn't already too late)!

Anonymous said...

To anon 10:43 - actually the revised dues formula worked out great. There are a small number of federations who have been misrepresenting their income for years under the old formula. Now at least there's consistency and honesty with the new formula. It's actually a big deal. If you don't recognize that then you're either clueless about what's going on or you're one of the former cheaters.