A friend wrote me out of her pain and I responded:
Too many, too many Jews, for reasons known only to them, have chosen to ignore what has been and is happening right in front of our eyes, on our own streets, in Charlottesville, now in our own synagogues, turning away from the anger and hate spewed out at every rally, a daily dose of vituperation toward the press, the media, the "other." Hell, it wasn't about us, was it?"Like you, I am sickened by what happened in Squirrel Hill this morning, by the further terrorist acts of this mad bomber this week, by President Trump’s response suggesting that what’s “needed” are more guns — in schools and, now, in synagogues — while his Secretary of Homeland Security is at the Mexican border to 'protect' America from an 'invasion' by 1,000 beset Hondurans/Nicaraguans. President Trump, with the acquiescence of his sycophants, has unleashed the darkness, and though his comments today at another rally were wholly appropriate, I don't believe that he has a clue of where to look to find the light."
We thought what has now happened to us, could only happen in Paris or Brussels or London -- somewhere else but never here. Yet here it is.
Friends, we have forgotten Pastor Niemoller's admonition and Santayana's maxim: those who forget history are doomed to repeat it. We are a People committed to "never forgetting" and, yet, too many of us have forgotten. We must commit to finding the means to ending the incitement, wherever and whenever we see it.
I despair even as I know that we, as a People, as a Jewish People in America, are strong, stronger than we have ever been -- but only if we can find our unity, only if we can find that unity. Who will rally us? How will he or she do so? Where will we find the words, the actions to rally our partners of all religions and races to join in common cause?
We must commit that we shall never forget those who perished today gathered in a synagogue in Pittsburgh while celebrating Shabbat and a bris -- perished at the hands of a virulent anti-semitic home grown terrorist.
We are already late.
Rwexler
Richard - At this time of extreme sadness your TDS is inappropriate and sad....
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteJust because Donald Trump says something, doesn’t make it wrong.
The best protection against an armed attack of a synagogue is an armed guard.
If there was an armed guard at the synagogue, in a worst case scenario, the guard would have been shot first giving an early warning to the congregants.
In the best case situation, that attacker would have backed down when challenged by the armed guard.
In all circumstances there would be more Jews alive. Your personal discomfort with firearms not withstanding, never take a knife to a gunfight.
If synagogues will face armed attacks, we will need armed guards.
I ontemplated not printing your Comment, given that you offer no alternative, but I decided what the heck. Maybe you will find the next Comment more to your liking.
ReplyDeleteThere were FOUR armed guards wounded by the assailant, who had an assault weapon, for goodness sakes.
ReplyDeleteOur President is beyond clueless. He is using this tragedy to pump up an organization that in so many ways has destroyed the lives of so many Americans.
And that doesn't even get into the vile anti-immigrant and anti-CNN/anti-opponent of Trump's rhetoric that applauds violence against the media and wants his opponents to be "locked up".
Any Jew that does not see the connection at this point should be ashamed of him or herself.
Anon 6:25 needs to get his/her facts right. There were NO armed guards present. There were, rather, 4 1st responders wounded. Big difference! TDS is alive and well in the comment section of this otherwise important blog.
ReplyDelete"TDS" does that apply only to those who embrace Trump unequivocally? Or does it also reference those who criticize Trump for his actions and statements tonight -- for example "I'm having a bad hair day and almost canceled this rally?" Really, who exactly is "deranged?"
ReplyDeleteOk. No more Comments today.
ReplyDeleteMore on topic, here's Pittsburgh Federation's statement:
ReplyDeletehttps://ejewishphilanthropy.com/shooting-at-pittsburgh-synagogue-leaves-at-least-4-dead-official-says/